Two-Stage Growth: Cases

MGMT 648 · September 17

Kerry Back

Thu Sep 17, 2026

John B. Sanfilippo & Son

The company

Shells, roasts and packages nuts. Fisher, Orchard Valley Harvest, Squirrel Brand, and private label for the grocery chains. Fiscal years end in late June.

Ticker

JBSS, $805 million of market value: 11.78 million diluted shares at $68.31.

What it owns

Shelling and roasting plants, $268 million of net PP&E against $1.18 billion of sales.

The balance sheet

Simple. The company owns no other businesses, and goodwill is $11.8 million against $659 million of assets.

Four years of history

$ millions FY2023 FY2024 FY2025 FY2026
Sales 999.7 1,066.8 1,107.2 1,175.7
Sales growth — 6.7% 3.8% 6.2%
Operating income 88.9 81.7 82.9 87.0
Operating margin 8.9% 7.7% 7.5% 7.4%
Net PP&E 127.2 178.6 193.0 268.3
Depreciation 22.1 26.6 31.5 33.3
Capital expenditure 20.7 28.3 50.7 88.1

Yahoo returns four years for JBSS, not five, and each ratio needs three.

The three ratios, measured

FY2023 FY2024 FY2025 FY2026
Net PP&E / next year’s sales (\(k\)) 11.9% 16.1% 16.4% —
Depreciation / opening net PP&E (\(d\)) — 20.9% 17.6% 17.3%
Working capital / next year’s sales (\(w\)) 15.7% 17.1% 21.1% —

\(k\) and \(w\) are measured against next year’s sales, so they stop at FY2025, the last year with a following year in the data.

Capital expenditure and net PP&E

Three years above depreciation

Capital expenditure of 28.3, 50.7, 88.1 against depreciation of 26.6, 31.5, 33.3. FY2023 was the last year capital expenditure ran below depreciation.

So net PP&E doubles

Net PP&E goes from 127.2 to 268.3 while sales rise 18%. The FY2024 step is a $59.0m acquisition, almost all of it plant. The FY2026 step is the build.

So \(k\) doubles

\(k\) goes from 11.9% to 16.4%, and is 21.6% measured against the FY2027 sales forecast.

The forecast has to say whether net PP&E stays this high relative to sales.

The other two ratios

\(d\) falls for a mechanical reason

\(d\) goes from 20.9% to 17.3%. New assets enter net PP&E faster than the existing assets are depreciated, so \(d\) falls even though the depreciable lives have not changed. Of the 268.3 balance, 86.9 is construction in progress, which does not depreciate until it is in service. Call \(d\) 15%.

\(w\) moves with inventory

\(w\) goes from 15.7% to 21.1%. Inventory alone is 245.8 against net working capital of 220.1, and a nut processor buys a crop once a year. Call \(w\) 18%.

The forecast

Item Assumption
Sales growth 5.5%, 5.0%, 4.5%, 3.5%, then 3.0%
Operating margin 7.5%, held
Net PP&E (\(k\)) 21.0% of next year’s sales
Depreciation (\(d\)) 15.0% of opening net PP&E
Working capital (\(w\)) 18.0% of next year’s sales
Tax rate 25%
WACC 9.0%

\(k\) holds near today’s 21.6% rather than the FY2025 level of 16.4%. The other rows are read off the history.

The capital schedule

$ millions FY26 FY27 FY28 FY29 FY30 FY31
Sales 1,175.7 1,240.4 1,302.4 1,361.0 1,408.6 1,450.9
Next year’s sales 1,240.4 1,302.4 1,361.0 1,408.6 1,450.9 1,494.4
Net PP&E 268.3 273.5 285.8 295.8 304.7 313.8
Depreciation — 40.2 41.0 42.9 44.4 45.7
Capital expenditure — 45.4 53.3 52.9 53.2 54.8
Working capital 220.1 234.4 245.0 253.6 261.2 269.0

The FY2026 column is the net PP&E and working capital the company already has.

Free cash flow

$ millions FY27 FY28 FY29 FY30 FY31
EBIT 93.0 97.7 102.1 105.6 108.8
Net operating profit after tax 69.8 73.3 76.6 79.2 81.6
Depreciation 40.2 41.0 42.9 44.4 45.7
Capital expenditure (45.4) (53.3) (52.9) (53.2) (54.8)
Increase in working capital (14.3) (10.5) (8.6) (7.6) (7.8)
Free cash flow 50.2 50.4 58.0 62.8 64.6

Working capital is positive, so sales growth consumes cash rather than releasing it.

Terminal value

FY2031 grows at 3.0% and all three ratios are fixed, so it is the steady-state year.

\[\text{TV}_{2031} = \frac{64.6 \times 1.03}{0.09-0.03} = 1{,}109.6\]

Seventeen times FY2031 free cash flow, at a six-point spread between \(r\) and \(g\). The example earlier was twenty-five times, at a four-point spread.

Discount it all back

$ millions FY27 FY28 FY29 FY30 FY31 TV
Free cash flow 50.2 50.4 58.0 62.8 64.6 1,109.6
Discount factor at 9% 0.917 0.842 0.772 0.708 0.650 0.650
Present value 46.1 42.4 44.8 44.5 42.0 721.2

$940.9m Enterprise value

77% In the terminal value

From enterprise value to equity

$ millions
Enterprise value 940.9
Less borrowings (83.5)
Plus cash 1.1
Plus goodwill and intangibles 15.2
Less other long-term liabilities (6.6)
Equity value 867.1
Diluted shares 11.78 million
Value per share $73.61

JBSS trades at $68.31.

What the market is assuming

Hold the five-year forecast fixed and solve for the terminal growth rate that justifies $68.31.

Implied growth

2.5% forever, against a 3.0% assumption.

Implied exit multiple

6.6 times FY2031 EBITDA.

Today’s multiple

7.3 times FY2026 EBITDA.

The price requires the EBITDA multiple to fall from 7.3 times FY2026 to 6.6 times FY2031.

Accounting

Leases: finance or operating

Does the lease hand over substantially all the risks and rewards of owning the asset? If so it is a purchase the lessor financed. Any one of five tests settles it.

  1. Ownership transfers at the end of the term
  2. There is a purchase option the lessee is reasonably certain to take
  3. The term covers a major part of the asset’s remaining economic life
  4. The payments are worth substantially all of the asset’s fair value
  5. The asset is so specialised it has no other use to the lessor

Meet none of the five and it is an operating lease.

Leases: what the choice is

Both sit on the balance sheet as a right-of-use asset and a lease liability. A finance lease splits into depreciation and interest; an operating lease is rent in EBIT.

Leave the rent in EBIT

The right-of-use asset stays out of invested capital and the lease liability out of the equity value calculation. The rent is already subtracted in EBIT.

Or capitalise the lease

Take the rent out of EBIT and depreciate the right-of-use asset in its place. The asset joins invested capital and the lease liability joins the equity value calculation.

Either is defensible. Half of the second — the lease liability subtracted in the equity value calculation, the rent still in EBIT — charges twice.

Leases: read the debt line twice

Yahoo reports total debt of 104.1. That is not what the company borrowed.

$ millions
Long-term debt 43.6
Current debt 39.9
Borrowings 83.5
Operating lease liability, non-current 20.6
Yahoo’s “total debt” 104.1

No finance leases. The rent is still inside the 87.0 of operating income, so the 20.6 is not subtracted when computing equity value. Subtracting it anyway lowers the value by $1.75 a share.

Deferred taxes: check, then ignore

FY2024 FY2025 FY2026
Book effective rate 24.6% 24.3% 25.4%
Cash taxes paid / pretax income 27.7% 27.2% 16.7%

Cash taxes ran 23.8% over the three years against a book rate of 24.8%. Taxing EBIT at the cash rate instead would add about $1.64 a share.

A one-point gap is small enough to leave the forecast taxing EBIT at the book rate.

Goodwill, intangibles, and other liabilities

Goodwill, $11.8m

1.8% of assets. No acquisitions are forecast, so goodwill is held flat and added in the equity value calculation, where it adds a dollar a share.

Other intangibles, $3.4m

Held flat and added in the equity value calculation too, where they add 29 cents a share.

Other long-term liabilities, $6.6m

The whole “other” category on the balance sheet, and the only one of these three items subtracted in the equity value calculation rather than added.

The three items together move the value per share by 73 cents, against a $5.30 gap to the market price.

One rule

Every balance sheet item goes in exactly one of two places.

Invested capital

An item goes here if it produces the operating cash flows being discounted. The change in the item is a cash flow in the forecast.

The equity value calculation

Every other item goes here, carried at book value between enterprise value and equity value.

Putting an item in both double counts it; leaving it out of both drops it from the valuation.

Sensitivity to \(k\)

Value per share
\(k\) back to 16.4%, the recent plant spending was a one-off $80.73
\(k\) at 21.0%, the base case $73.61
\(k\) at 21.6%, today’s level holds $72.68

\(d\) does not appear in this table, and cannot. Capital expenditure less depreciation is the change in the net PP&E balance, and EBIT here is a margin on sales rather than EBITDA less depreciation. So \(d\) cancels out of the valuation.

If there is time

Smith-Midland

Precast concrete: highway barriers, sound walls, building panels. SMID, $130 million of market value at $24.54 a share.

$ millions FY2022 FY2023 FY2024 FY2025
Sales 50.1 59.6 78.5 93.4
Sales growth — 18.8% 31.8% 19.0%
Operating margin 1.7% 1.9% 12.6% 18.2%
Net PP&E 25.1 27.7 31.7 38.5
Depreciation 2.9 2.4 2.7 2.9
Capital expenditure 2.7 5.0 6.2 9.3

The three ratios, measured

FY2022 FY2023 FY2024 FY2025
\(k\) 42.2% 35.3% 33.9% —
\(d\) — 9.5% 9.6% 9.1%
\(w\) 19.6% 11.2% 14.9% —

\(k\) in the mid-thirties is nearly twice JBSS’s \(k\): a concrete plant carries just under three dollars of sales per dollar of net PP&E. \(d\) holds between 9.1% and 9.6%. The operating margin is the line that moves, from 1.7% to 18.2%.

The forecast

Item Assumption
Sales growth 12%, 9%, 6%, then 3%
Operating margin 13.0%, down from 18.2%
Net PP&E (\(k\)) 36.0% of next year’s sales
Depreciation (\(d\)) 9.5% of opening net PP&E
Working capital (\(w\)) 18.0% of next year’s sales
Tax rate, WACC 25%, 11%

Everything but the operating margin is read off the history.

The schedule and the cash flow

$ millions FY25 FY26 FY27 FY28 FY29
Sales 93.4 104.6 114.0 120.9 124.5
Net PP&E 38.5 41.0 43.5 44.8 46.2
Depreciation — 3.7 3.9 4.1 4.3
Capital expenditure — 6.2 6.4 5.4 5.6
Working capital 23.2 20.5 21.8 22.4 23.1
Free cash flow — 10.3 7.4 9.8 10.1

FY2026 working capital falls because the assumed \(w\) of 18% is below the 22.2% the company carried at FY2025. A ratio assumption applied to an actual balance always steps in year one.

The value

\[\text{TV}_{2029} = \frac{10.1 \times 1.03}{0.11-0.03} = 130.3\]

$ millions
Present value of FY26 to FY29 29.2
Present value of terminal value 85.8
Enterprise value 115.0
Plus cash, less debt 11.9, (4.5)
Equity value 122.4
Value per share, on 5.31m shares $23.05

The margin implied by the price

$23.05 At a 13.0% margin

$24.54 The market price

13.7% The margin that closes the gap

Three quarters of the value is in the terminal value, which rests on the assumed operating margin. The company earned 1.7% in FY2022 and 18.2% in FY2025.

Assignment

Flexsteel

Value Flexsteel the way we valued JBSS. Yahoo Finance, ticker FLXS, fiscal years ending June 30.

What it does

Makes and sells upholstered furniture. Four years of data, FY2023 through FY2026.

Why this one

All three ratios move over the four years, so each one has to be defended rather than read off the history.

What to pull

Statement Lines
Income statement Revenue, operating income, pretax income, tax provision, diluted shares
Balance sheet Cash, current assets, current liabilities, current debt, net PP&E, total debt, operating lease liability
Cash flow Depreciation and amortisation, capital expenditure

Net working capital is current assets less cash, minus current liabilities less current debt.

Part 1: the three ratios

Compute, for every year the data allows:

  1. \(k\), net PP&E as a share of next year’s sales
  2. \(d\), depreciation as a share of opening net PP&E
  3. \(w\), net working capital as a share of next year’s sales

Report each ratio year by year. Two of the three fall by about a third over the four years and the third rises. Say what single fact about the company explains all three, and whether that change is finished.

Part 2: the forecast

Item Assumption
Sales growth 5.0%, 4.5%, 4.0%, then 3.0%
Operating margin 8.5%, held
Net PP&E (\(k\)) 16.0% of next year’s sales
Depreciation (\(d\)) 5.0% of opening net PP&E
Working capital (\(w\)) 16.0% of next year’s sales
Tax rate 25%
WACC 10.5%

Use these, not your own averages, so the answers are comparable.

Part 3: the value

  1. The capital schedule and free cash flow for FY2027 to FY2030
  2. Terminal value at the end of FY2030, and the enterprise value
  3. Equity value per share, and the comparison to the market price
For the equity value calculation, at FY2026 $ millions
Borrowings 0.0
Operating lease liability 51.9
Cash 16.7
Share price $82.11

The share count is not in the table. Part 4 asks for it.

Part 4: the accounting

Answer in a sentence each.

The depreciable life

Your \(d\) will come out near 4%, an implied life above twenty years for a furniture maker’s plant. Explain the long implied life, and name the balance sheet line that is the evidence.

The debt line

Yahoo reports total debt of 51.9 and the company has no borrowings. Say what the 51.9 is, whether it belongs in your equity value calculation, and what you would have to change in the forecast to put it there.

Diluted average shares for FY2026 are 5.46 million. Shares outstanding on the cover of the 10-K are 4.11 million. Say which one belongs in the equity value calculation, why, and what happened between the two dates.

What to hand in

The spreadsheet

One tab of history, one of the forecast. Assumptions in their own cells, not buried in formulas.

The ratios

Year by year, with the missing years marked and explained.

One page

Your value per share, the gap to the market price, and the three accounting answers from Part 4.